If catholics are right, I'm automatically screwed

Discussion in 'Religion' started by stainless, May 11, 2008.

  1. KLJ

    KLJ Really Smart Guy

    How does a baby sin? Lots of ways. When we were feeding my daughter (she's 2 now) individiually wrapped cheese slices, we would tear the cheese into pieces and feed them to her one at a time. She would inevitably fail to eat the piece in her hand while crying for more. The cheese was a treat, not a necessity. And she didn't trust us to provide for her. That's greed. Right now she's in a very clingy mood with her mother. Not for any particular reason other than selfishness. Two sins right there. Given more time, I could come up with more. I'm on lunch break right now. So, she needs the cleansing witnessed to in baptism. Fortunately, it's already been given to her.

    The problem for me with saying babies/kids can't sin is the question of "when do they start?" Because some kids are smarter than other and might hold off longer. And if they can hold off for a while, shouldn't we work to keep them sinless? And if we can do that, than salvation is in our hands, not God's.

    It was the Virgin Mary who was supposed to have been conceived immaculately. The thinking is that a woman under the curse of Original Sin couldn't bear the Son of God. So Mary is supposed to have been conceived in some sort of miracle without sin. But the Virgin Mary didn't receive an immaculate conception. She didn't need it. Jesus was born without sin because he was/is the Word (2nd person of the Trinity) of God. God doesn't need to be protected, which the immaculate conception in essence does, from the humans and their sin. Particularly protected BY the humans. If we can't protect ourselves, how can we protect God? Remember, salvation work didn't start with us. It starts with God. The Word (God) became flesh and dwelt among us.
     
  2. Phoenix21

    Phoenix21 New Member

    Exactly, it doesn't start with us. It's God that salvation starts with. And please pardon my ignorance, but I don't understand the point you are trying to make with that part? I don't mean that as rude or anything, lol, I just don't see the point. Ignorance on my part, and if someone could point it out to me that would be appreciated. :)

    Phoenix :cool:
     

Share This Page