Defending my religion...

Discussion in 'Religion' started by David, May 14, 2008.

  1. David

    David Proud Enemy of Hillary

    I have decided to refrain from commenting any further on this rash of irresponsible, anti-Catholic postings because I see them for what they are- ignorant ramblings from a couple of immature kids who are looking for spiritual guidance from strangers on the internet while trying to get a rise out of/pick a fight with other members.
    My advice is this: Rather than start rumors, spread lies, cite internet stories as fact (I loved the link that bashed Catholics as well as gave you tips on cooking in a crock pot), confer with "pastors", etc simply attend a Catholic Mass and decide for yourself. I'm a life-long Catholic and a regular attendee of Mass. I have never heard my current Priest or any former Priest talk about anything beyond loving thy brother and doing our share to make the world a better place. And yes, we read from the Bible at every mass and even have Bible study classes!! The Pope isn't worshipped but rather respected as God's representative on Earth. We pray to saints in Heaven to intercede on our behalf...sorta put a bug in God's ear for us- having more prayer can only work for us, right?
    Disagree with a Catholic principal? Fine, every Christian-based church is an offshoot of the Catholic Church & the reason for the original seperation can surely be traced to some different intrepretation or disagreement with Catholic teachings. Every church has aspects that outsiders view as hypocritical but you know what? It works for them so more power to 'em.
     
  2. Bonedigger

    Bonedigger Another Wandering Celt

    Chuckle, glad they didn't get my (born and raised Catholic, but not a practicing now) wife riled up, who would have ended up getting both of us almost banned again, LOL...

    Me, I'm simply a Christian and see no problem, have no anger towards, and will not slam another individual about how they observe their worship of Christ. Or any other religion for that matter as long as it doesn't advocate death, destruction, pedophelia, and subjication.

    FWIW, she's exploring the roots of Irish/Celtic Christianity and how current Christian worship habits relate to the ancient Celtic practices, the Wicker-Man festival excluded of course. ;) It's pretty interesting and enlightening.

    Ben
     
  3. clembo

    clembo Well-Known Member

    Well put both David and Bonedigger.

    I think I make my views pretty clear on the whole subject and we can't all agree.

    It's odd how the negative aspects of religion get focused on and I will admit, in a heartbeat, that I am guilty of this. At least I'm honest about it.

    While I don't have a great deal of respect for "religion(s)" there are always positives as well. Beliefs and faith have gotten a lot of people through some very tough times and I'm good with that.

    As long as one is not espousing the things Bone mentioned it's fine. Whatever floats your boat.

    Now David - I may have egged the other thread on a bit in hindsight. Not meant as a malicious gesture trust me on that. Not sure the others were either actually.

    My real intention was to get things out in the open as it were. Guess I did. It happens and I suppose it will again.
    You know me by now;)

    clembo
     
  4. stainless

    stainless New Member


    Ok bro,

    everyone here knows you are talking about me. So lets get this strait.

    First off, I'm not immature, and either you failed to miss my whole point on the story, or you're just trying to make me look stupid.

    In the first post, I said it was a RUMOR...and then I stated how if the Pope did say that, it was wrong. Then you came in, called me immature, a liar, and that my story was BS.

    So, I decided to make another thread just for you to show that I wasn't making the story up, and that the Pope actually did say this.

    All I wanted to know was that how can anyone tell someone else that they are not a "True Christain".

    I showed you that the Pope said it, and if he is god's "representative", then doesn't he have a BIG say so on this subject.

    Also, if my pastor(..oh wait, my bad...My Priest....) told me this, then isn't that enough for me to believe that this is what Catholics think? Or do you want me to go ask the Pope himself?

    Fact is, I could write a big list of things that arent right with the catholic church (HINT: Pergitory), but I just threw that post out there to see what you guys thought. you claim it as a BS story, and now your defending that the Pope never said that you will go to hell if you're not catholic. Defending with nothing but your word.

    And, this just isn't for the Catholics, I may have used them because this is what inspired my thread, but how can any religion tell anyone they are going to hell?

    And where do you come up with the assumption that I want a fight with other members? I wanted to know what you guys think. If you think something different than what I do, then that's ok. We can discuss our points of view. I'm not the one calling the other immature.

    Stainless
     
  5. De Orc

    De Orc Well-Known Member

    OK keep it cool guy's :D
     
  6. clembo

    clembo Well-Known Member

    We're trying but what are the two things you don't discuss with friends? Politics is one. Take a wild guess at the other. ;)
     
  7. Phoenix21

    Phoenix21 New Member

    First off, let me start off stating that I am sorry that I offended you. I had a fear this would happen, but, if we lived in constant fear of talking and saying something that "it might offend someone", then we would all probably be walking around with duct tape over our mouths, lol. But I meant no disrespect, and I did not intend in the least to insult you. I admit, I have not ever been to a catholic mass, or a service, but I am going by what I have heard and read, but numbers of people. Keep in mind too, there are different variations of catholism out there, and they all do practice different if you look at it.

    I also have friends that are catholic. Does that make me like or dislike them more? Heck no. I don't try to go Bible thumping them, making them convert, but I do try to live my life as example. I don't go around saying "You're wrong, and I'm right!", I just try to work with them, and be friend, like I would any other person, catholic, jewish, atheist, whatever. But I am sorry if you took my posts as disrespect to you, and to your religion, but I do still stand by what I said.

     
  8. Phoenix21

    Phoenix21 New Member

    Poetry, or coins? :D

    Phoenix :cool:
     

Share This Page