Wrong to choose sex of child

Discussion in 'Religion' started by angie828, Feb 11, 2011.

  1. angie828

    angie828 New Member

    If you had the option of choosing which sex your child would be, could you bring yourself to do this? I really do not think that I could. I would not care if it were a boy or a girl as long as it lived a happy healthy life.
     
  2. De Orc

    De Orc Well-Known Member

    Woudnt do it personaly, the same as I woudnt want to know the sex prior to the birth
     
  3. angie828

    angie828 New Member

    I agree with that as well De Orc. I would want it to be a surprise.
     
  4. pk_boomer

    pk_boomer New Member

    There are serious ethical issues with "designer babies" - I don't think people should be able to artificially select the gender of their babies without a good reason (personal preference not being a good reason!) However we chose to find out the gender of both our babies before they were born. We wanted to be able to prepare for them well in advance (clothes, wall colors etc.) and we figured it was still a surprise when we found out!
     
  5. angie828

    angie828 New Member

    Glad that you agree with us. But could you tell me what you may think a good reason is? Right off hand I am thinking of none.
     
  6. pk_boomer

    pk_boomer New Member

    I was thinking if there were a good medical reason, such as if the parents knew that there was a good chance that if they had a boy that he would inherit a serious gender specific genetic condition from his parents. I don't know that there is such a thing, but I didn't want to rule it or any similar scenario out entirely.
     
  7. angie828

    angie828 New Member

    Good thought there. I never thought about that.
     
  8. pk_boomer

    pk_boomer New Member

    I don't like to rule anything out, because real life is not black and white - there are always shades of grey, and each case has to be considered on its own. The circumstances and context of every situation should be taken into consideration when deciding what is "right" or "fair". Deciding important issues like this with black and white absolutes can lead to trouble.
     
  9. angie828

    angie828 New Member

    YOu are very right PK. I totally agree with you there. If there is some reason for it that is one thing. But to just say I want a girl and have no valid reason is wrong.
     
  10. IQless1
    Blah

    IQless1 trump supporters are scum

    NEVER! (laughs) Before my son was born a nurse was doing an ultrasound on my gf and asked if we wanted to know if it was a boy or girl. Although both of us immediately said "No!", it was really already too late. Just by asking I knew it was a boy, but in case my gf didn't catch that I didn't mention it to her.
     
  11. pk_boomer

    pk_boomer New Member

    We found out the gender of both our kids as soon as we could. Only because we wanted to know what color to paint the bedrooms, what kind of clothes to buy, etc. beforehand. I guess we're too practical for our own good =)
     

Share This Page