Does prayer work?

Discussion in 'Religion' started by stainless, May 8, 2008.

  1. stainless

    stainless New Member

    Do you think it does and why?

    there's really no way to prove it.


    stainless
     
    2 people like this.
  2. De Orc

    De Orc Well-Known Member

    Here we are again LOL with that word Prove!! If prayer can give someone the strength to go on in the face of adversity then it works If prayer can give meaning back to life for a person then it works :D
    Now prove to me that prayer and faith do not work :D
     
  3. stainless

    stainless New Member

    I just said theres no way to prove it.;)

    meaning-you cant prove it does work and you cant prove it doesnt

    stainless
     
  4. De Orc

    De Orc Well-Known Member

    Prayer is a act of faith and if it as I have said above works for a individual to help them then the case for prayer is proven ;) I have not said it works in every case, look at it on a individual basis, also have not said it works for big things like world peace or the lottery :D
     
  5. clembo

    clembo Well-Known Member

    If you prayed for the Patriots to win the Super Bowl then no.

    When I see someone mention a bad thing that has happened to them (like Bonedigger's daughter in a car accident) I do not send out my prayers. I do send out my best.

    On the other hand his daughter will be okay. Did prayer work? To an extent I'm sure it did. Why? - because so many people replied with kind words or prayers that it made the whole Bonedigger clan feel better.

    If prayer merely gives one comfort in times of duress then yes it works.

    clembo
     
    2 people like this.
  6. Bonedigger

    Bonedigger Another Wandering Celt

    Thank you Clembo, they all helped. She got her jaw unwired on Tuesday and has been eating us out of House and Home. Again Thank You very much.

    Norman Vincent Peale wrote several books about thoughts just like this discussion I believe...
     
  7. clembo

    clembo Well-Known Member

    No problem Ben.

    Should we start a food drive? :)

    clembo
     
  8. Bonedigger

    Bonedigger Another Wandering Celt

    Naw, not necessary. ;) You'd be surprised what I've found in the bottom of the freezer, LOL...
     
  9. stainless

    stainless New Member


    Good to hear she's doing okay bonedigger.:D

    stainless
     
  10. De Orc

    De Orc Well-Known Member

  11. Bonedigger

    Bonedigger Another Wandering Celt

    Thanks guys (Clembo, Stainless, and De Orc) it means alot. :)
     
  12. stainless

    stainless New Member

    Wow....that's a lot of food....and the Hamburger loks so good...lol;)
     
  13. tonylynch

    tonylynch New Member

    Glad to hear she's doin' better, Ben.
     
  14. KLJ

    KLJ Really Smart Guy

    Why is the assumption made that the prayer is effective only if what's asked for is received? For example, I could pray for Bonedigger's daughter, whom I wouldn't know from a hole in the ground. I'm glad that my prayers offered comfort to Bonedigger and his family, but all I know about him is his screen name and avatar. But if those same prayers gave me the willingness to stop and talk to a lonely-looking person on my hospital run, then those prayers have worked. A sick person is feeling better. Prayer has worked. I've also found that praying for my sister-in-law - with whom I've not always had the best relationship - made getting along with her easier. Prayer works.

    BTW, I wasn't trying to demean Bonedigger or his daughter. I am truly thankful for her ongoing healing, and pray (that again!) that it shall continue.
     
  15. Stu Joe

    Stu Joe New Member

    Personally, I typically only pray to give thanks for something or to be forgiven for something, not to ask for something that hasn't happened or that I want to happen. So I probably can't say if it 'works' in the way that you are probably referring to.
     
  16. Phoenix21

    Phoenix21 New Member

    It's tough to answer your question, lol, cause I am not sure what you are asking. Just because you pray for something, and it doesn't happen, doesn't mean it doesn't works IMHO. IMHO, there is no such thing as "unanserwed" prayer, because you either get a yes, no, or a wait till later. ;)

    Phoenix :cool:
     
  17. David

    David Proud Enemy of Hillary

    I pray for strength, for widsom, for patience, etc...seems to always work for me:)
     
  18. stainless

    stainless New Member

    If we go by this, then my lucky horseshoe works too;)

    If this is how he does it, then how do we know if he answers them or not?
     
  19. Phoenix21

    Phoenix21 New Member

    If you get it, He most likely said yes, if you don't, then it was probably a "no" or a wait. :D

    Phoenix :cool:
     
  20. KLJ

    KLJ Really Smart Guy

    So you want an answer to your prayer RIGHT NOW!!! There were times when I asked a question of my mother and she responded "Your father and I will discuss it when he gets home." Does that mean that my parents didn't exist until I got a "yes" or a "no?"
     

Share This Page